OH. I’m So Confused!

OK. Taylor is definitely making it through. He rocked the American Idol stage with “Jailhouse Rock” and then slowed it down with “In The Ghetto.” In fact, Taylor sealed the deal last night in my mind! After that it’s a toss up.
Katharine shook it like a saltshaker, but she forgot to spice up the lyrics. Come on, you’re in the final four baby. YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER THE WORDS. And her version of “I Can’t Help Falling In Love With You” was boring.
Chris’ first song was aieet, but his second performance was ... well ... a little bit on the meeh side.
Elliot. Elliot brought it like UPS — on time and undamaged. He kicked ... ask anyone. I know I said yesterday that he’s probably going to go home, but Elliot really does deserve to stay.
Going back on my statement yesterday ... after forgetting the words and performing and beautiful song with the grace of a blender on frappe ... I think Katharine should be going home. But note the word “should.”
It really could be anyone except Taylor.

Could she be going home? Katharine McPhee sings on American Idod broadcast on April 25.
Photo Courtesy of AP and Fox Television